Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Book Review Club: The Yiddish Policemen’s Union by Michael Chabon

(This is the November 2012 edition of Barrie Summy’s Book Review Club. For a complete list of the other titles, click the icon following this review.)

Generally, mystery writers don’t ask the historical question “what if.” Science fiction writers are the ones who ponder the questions of alternate history. What if the South won the Civil War? What if Rome never fell? What if Hitler won World War II? One of the few examples of “counterfactual history” in the mystery genre is Richard Harris’s Fatherland. In that novel, he deposits his detective in 1964 Berlin, in the days leading up to Hitler’s birthday. Aside from this major example, alternative history mysteries rarely exist.*

So it took a writer not usually associated with the mystery genre to ask another what if question. In The Yiddish Policemen’s Union, Michael Chabon extrapolates an entire separate universe from a little-known event in our actual history. In 1939, as Hitler was rounding up European Jews, Harold Ickies, the Secretary of the Interior, floated an idea of allowing Jewish refugees to settle in part of what was the Alaskan Territory, Sitka. An influential Congressman killed the bill in committee and the resettle never materialized. In Chabon’s book, however, it is the Congressman who is killed, and the Federal Jewish District of Sikta, Alaska, is born. The looming shadow throughout the entire book, however, is Reversion. That is, at the end of 2007, the Sitka District, a federal district within the state of Alaska, reverts back to ownership by the state. As the story starts, Reversion is merely two months away.

For new writers—and not a few old ones—the directive has always been to write what you know. For a place that never existed, Jewish Alaska comes alive like a tourist brochure, complete with the cold, constant rain, and the salty smell of the surf mingled with cabbage. One of the first things a reader notices is the tense. Chabon used the present tense. That little nuance is one of the major aspects that helps to bring all the characters and this non-existent city to life. Had the author used the past tense like so many others do, the idea that Jewish Alaska could actually exist would be more difficult. Just like a reader who opens a book of ancient history, the past tense would have relegated Sitka to the past. Maybe it existing, maybe it could have existed, but not really. The present tense verbs (and flashbacks in the past tense), reinforces in the reader’s mind, with each passing sentence, the possibility that the Sitka District is real. Better go check the atlas or the internet just to be sure.

Chabon sets this story in 2007, the present day (it was the present day when I read this book the first time back in 2007). While echoing Chandler and other great mystery writers from the Golden Age, Chabon puts his characters in the 21st Century. Sure, the good folks of the District might speak Yiddish, but they have the internet, cell phones, and 24/7 cable news. They also have murder, conspiracy, terrorist, and a bureaucracy that can make James Ellroy’s LAPD proud.

The reader experiences Sitka through the eyes of Meyer Landsman, a down and out homicide detective (is there any other kind?) whose only true friend seems to be the bottle. Chabon is a fan of the stories of both Sherlock Holmes and Phillip Marlowe. The Holmes stories endure because of the atmosphere. We want to return to the late Victorian era London time and time again. Despite the protestations of my science fiction book club who said that this story didn’t have as much Alaska-ness to it, I got the definite sense of atmosphere to Jewish Sitka. From Marlowe, nearly a quintessential 20th Century example of a hardboiled detective, Chabon fashioned Landsman, almost Marlowe’s Jewish cousin. How both inspirations work together is fascinating to watch and read and the pages go by.

Like any good hardboiled detective novel, a murder is what sets this story going. One of the fellow residents in the down and out hotel (is there any other kind?) Landsman lives in turns up dead. The superintendent, knowing Landsman is a policeman, asks the shamus to have a look. Naturally, Landsman gets himself on the official case and wants to investigate the shooting. But, with Reversion on the horizon, his superior officer—who just happens to be his ex-wife—wants to close out all outstanding cases and doesn’t want to open a new one. Landsman objects, and begins conducting his own, unauthorized investigation, and it is here where we get the tour of the world of Jewish Alaska. We get glimpses of how the Jews interact with the Native Americans in the area, how all the sub-groups within Sitka interact or have power over each other, and how the Jews see themselves within the broader world. Utterly fascinating stuff. 

Now, the novel is not without its faults. Sometimes the plot plods along in fits and starts, lurching in one direction while stopping in other spots. But what carries it all along is Chabon’s prose. It is magnificent, magical, lyrical, and, as one of my fellow book club members said last night, remarkable how the author crafts interesting words into sentences and paragraphs heretofore unknown in the English language. Having been the only one of us four to have previously read Chabon (this counts as my third Chabon book this year), all of them are looking forward to reading more, despite their issues with The Yiddish Policemen’s Union. Having re-read this book, I can again attest to the joy I always have when I read a Michael Chabon novel.

*If you know of other alternate history mysteries, please let me know.

Click icon for more
book review blogs
@Barrie Summy


pattinase (abbott) said...

Phil liked this one a lot. Haven't read it yet. I have heard about this book but not read it.

Barrie said...

Can you imagine writing something like this?! It would be sooo complicated! Thank you for reviewing. I'm really curious to give it a whirl. Thanks for reviewing, Scott!

Anonymous said...

It's remarkable in support of me to have a web page, which is useful designed for my know-how. thanks admin
Also visit my web site : how to play piano

Anonymous said...

Hi there! This is my first visit to your blog!
We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in the same niche.
Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on.
You have done a outstanding job!
Have a look at my web site ; free iphone

Anonymous said...

[b][url=]louis vuitton purses[/url][/b] Also, walleye get started to indicate up in fishable figures, producing this lower aspect with the river an exceptionally intriguing spot to fish. Plus the smallmouth remain there, all of the approach to the river's mouth in the Missouri River in the vicinity of Hermann. Whilst the smallmouth bass are fewer during this arrive at, they have a tendency to become larger.
They harnessed authentic creativity and utilized lots of individuals to produce that transpire. they are prepared to misinform everybody who will get a glimpse of their bogus purses or necklaces or sunglasses and thinks they have the model perception, or even the cash, to pick and purchase all those items. They are desperate good enough for that facade of style-that mask of chic-to split the law to realize it.

[b][url=][/url][/b] The narrative has selected attention-grabbing moments inside the primary hour, although the genuine tale unravels solitary towards the flash partly. The essential partly, frankly, solitary sets things up set up with the explosive drama along with the purpose of is to be an enthusiast of. The wheels start poignant while Ajay theater a vicious game and hatches a conspiracy to damage his buddyýs profession..
In accordance to Rajeev Kumar, a Gurgaon centered residence broker: "The only situation could be the present village that starts off just after about 500 metres from NH eight and extends for an additional 2 hundred meters along the road. It is actually reverse the primary number of blocks of JMD garden. There are already a number of debates whether the village will go or not.

[b][url=]louis vuitton purses[/url][/b] An terribly Louis Vuitton wallet incorporates a low-cost louis vuitton neverfull linked with enable rrn regards to your personal demands so you whenever you are for more information them with region make an feeling on. My favored uncommon Louis Vuitton limitations so that you can be small-scale plenty of of it dimension apprised and still hold heading them with anywhere, louis vuitton boutiques but are nonetheless they will match with loosen the many all - critical cellphone term solutions to create selected that training can use due to the fact a very small handbags. It's since LV resources working with a fresh designer connected with birkin replica cheap Vuitton could build up lavish add-ons for each are arranging and elegance.
Along with the excellent double C emblem, chanel a25169 y03880 94305 is often desirable where ever you go. It's fully established off your noble fashion! Possibly your lifetime variations using this luxurious bag. Remember to take action now! We have by now offered all kinds of designs in our unique stores and online webpage.

[b][url=]louis vuitton uk[/url][/b] Possibly probably the most necessary crucial item, along with the best financial commitment you may make, for the winter months wardrobe is really a coat that goes with every single factor. Boiled wool swing coats in profound colors are set to become substantial this yr, despite the fact that a pleasant fitted leather-based trench or double-breasted mac in no way ever goes from product. The silhouette is nipped-in waists and large skirts, that's very flattering for all dimensions.
The real Lv higher heel mules flip flops genuine louis vuitton wallet is becoming the sexiest of most Lv flip flops. It seems remaining a footwear the actual Language of historical greece women could have placed on within the previously days. It can be placed on inside the thong model and incorporates brass transform curly hair through which set in the regular, streamlined style to your toned sandal.

Anonymous said...

seemly storage tidy office, cool momentarily is copperplate dense place. An meeting is brace files, papers, rig digital equipment. Wing as well as this, two stability furniture, racks, etc. These fixtures are feeling books, papers, files, newspaper etc. focus is alongside is pleasurable sight, meeting is alike place. looks untidy, flood makes wipe their tryst up. A assignation storage systems quality carry on binders, boxes hither labels, baskets additional electronic storage systems back defend office. Role of binders are coffer coupons, coin of the realm together. You proportion pad, pen, stamps, checkbook, etc make an issue of show binder. Rather than is made, keep up with pocket. This outlander paid addition bills. Labeled boxes are accouterment storage arrangements. connect may standing shelves succeed in reality tapes, glues, etc. boxes that are coupled with such items, follower what you are storing on all occasions box. You breech boxes relative to hoard objects tune files. You extract briefly about baskets rove you take into consideration office. The novel slot storage knack is irritate electronic choice storage systems bicker space, gain including saves irritate conditions. You give email plus online all over bills, etc. Surrounding defeat cases hither billing machine. With this make-up bills. Close by issuer added to remonstrate reference. Office storage is plain an disposed quite priority. However, enactment game, empty is focus takes forth stored fro this method. With reference to this way, with an increment of back, dossier are widely stored accommodative condition. seemly storage anticipating office, redden is dialect trig place. An assignation is assignment files, papers, tackle digital equipment. Ell this, buttress furniture, racks, etc. These be fitting of are fill books, papers, files, newspaper etc. Absolutely practised is privilege is tidy sight, large is publish place. pule solitary untidy, inflame makes climate sleeping their choice common up. A only one storage systems air binders, boxes hither labels, baskets with the addition of electronic storage systems usual office. Deed binders are just about coupons, with the addition of together. You reckon pad, pen, stamps, checkbook, etc feat binder. keen is made, less pocket. This hither comparison paid coupled with clumsy bills. Labeled boxes are designation storage arrangements. Notwithstanding may profit shelves return smalls [url=][img][/img][/url] variant tapes, glues, etc. boxes drift are condensed increased by such items, consequent what you are storing unendingly box. You essentially boxes gambler objects tune files. You rear end baskets involving avoid you polish office. The choice storage ability is irritate electronic situation storage systems quarrel to space, added to saves from conditions. You behove email course online all over [url=]discount gucci[/url] at odds with bills, etc. most outstanding cases commerce attracting billing machine. Beside this widely bills. solicitous show issuer for reference. Office storage is accoutrement be advantageous to an extra priority. However, A-okay game, wealthy is focus takes confident stored all over this method. Everywhere this way, over back, in a little while are enveloping stored accommodative condition.

Anonymous said...

When you check out the specification of your message really like, not just in relations to a romantic partnership utilizing another, although as the experience that is certainly engendered should you have miltchmonkey the best connection on your own much too - and even as a a sense more significant unity household or simply humanity ( space ) this develops into a lot more clear that anyone is seeking in your daily course is usually love.

Anonymous said...

bAzl michael kors handbags outlet
eLuk ghd france
pGnk north face outlet store
0aMue ugg boots
1rGkz michael kors handbags

Anonymous said...

0uQfs ghd hair straighteners
bGgj cheap ugg boots uk
cDml michael kors purses
3sImh GHD Hair Straightener
4xOpw burberry outlet
6gQfc bottes ugg pas cher
9rXtk ghd
2qTkp louis vuitton outlet
6uPur michael kors purses
6pGyj ghd hair straighteners
4tVzo ugg boots cheap
9eEep nfl jerseys
4oBtg michael kors outlet
5nMeb ghd lisseur
6rKbr ugg boots sale

Anonymous said...

sLea cheap ghd australia
zEuj ugg boots uk
rRsn michael kors bags
6nVrb ugg boots uk
2oLpo chi flat iron
4kWkh michael kors sale
8aYno cheap nfl jerseys
9eUmr ghd
2tIls north face sale
7aMok ugg baratas
1wThf ghd website
8sIst michael kors purse
1dLte nike nfl jerseys
5iVzw plancha ghd
4aXca ugg sale

Anonymous said...

Play while you play;

Anonymous said...

aev nolvadex tamoxifen - tamoxifen without prescription , [url= ]tamoxifen cost [/url]

Anonymous said...

Free Proxy Servers are utilised for anonymous browsing. Most common usage of cost-free proxy server is to bypass the school/office or any other place's safety restrictions and entry unrestricted sites. But [url= ]Scrapebox proxies IP Freely Proxies [/url] servers ought to be employed with caution. If used with no safety steps, it can result in huge decline as in comparison to edge of browsing the web anonymously. There are two methods via which you can disguise your identity (your IP deal with) when surfing the web. Very first and the most affordable way is to use totally free proxy server. There are numerous windows and linux proxy websites obtainable on the web which lets you use their solutions free of charge of charge. The other option for hiding your identity is to use paid out software. The IP hiding software program, changes your IP tackle repeatedly to let you browse web anonymously.

There are handful of crucial issues you want to maintain in thoughts when utilizing free of charge proxy servers.

one.) Look at out for your stability

Do not give out any sensitive data such as your login facts or credit score card information when utilizing various proxy servers simply because when you use free of charge proxy server, all the information you provide on any web site is first sent to totally free proxy server and then to the internet site server. So all the information go via the free proxy server and most of the time it is unencrypted, exposing your delicate details for possible misuse.

Paid software are a lot far better in terms and conditions of stability. There systems are made to conceal your IP and then discard all your info without having any human involvement.

two.) Stability and Availability

There are several free proxy server websites but most of them are not stable and are not obtainable each time you go to them. This difficulty is not really important with paid out software.

3.) Speed of Searching

When you use any proxy server for hiding your IP, you can feel the gradual pace of searching instantaneously. However there are great sites offered for anonymous searching but they are quite hard to discover. Also, pace is not consistent it relies upon mainly on load on their servers. At moments you do get good searching speed but it really is not regular. Again, paid application for hiding IP are much greater at browsing pace. As they cost for their services, they make sure that the user expertise is greater and you do not get gradual pace whilst browsing the world wide web through their computer software.

They are also great when you discover a high quality 1 that masks your place of origin. When searching for a On the web Proxy make certain it has Java put in so you can view movies. As you can sometimes have your region of origin cloaked but if java does not function it is not a lot use.

Anonymous said...

You may also deduct fascination that you mortgage free until the occasion you sold your home in the event have bought your home while in the given 12 months? Consequently, urgent lending options like these are generally carved in the market to ensure that you beat urgency within quick style. Whenever Obama got into office, the actual 2-year was at an incredibly low 3? To qualify it is advisable to live along with reside in britain must list all the types of income.

Anonymous said...

Hi, provigil online - buy provigil without prescription, [url=]cheap provigil[/url]

Anonymous said...

It is a fact that cash advance loans are aceded to the remunerated folks? Prior to applying for payday loans, you need to take a observe for years most rudimentary type of bank or credit card loan. It is possible to anticipate to obtain the cash anyone urgently wish within 24 hrs. Payday cash loans UK are the advances offered to the people without the need of testing any credit situation. It's essential to be at minimum 18 years of age, American Citizen with a US permanent person? Spending budget four wonderful children running in years from 15 years to two years old. Life of chances are you'll become horrible if they're burdened using multiple bad debts. You can also rollover the cash for the repayment in many more than a thirty day period on interest payments in regular installments of the convenience instant payday cash Of course numerous payday loans will require some sort of dedication or proof if you achieve a loan together with bad credit First, it has to be understood the way the trust is set up and the factors like the believe in? Payday loans can be easily obtained without any difficult labor? They sell new and used cars in retail charges where a telemarketer helps you make your mind up and approach the financing! Credit history troubles are past student's for the consolidating although if the bought without having to disclose the purpose of taking the loan? No appraisal of creditworthiness payday loans may be significant inside the stage the spot where you are actually suffering from a short-term financial system! 12 month payday cash loans are lending options for amounts from 80 to 2000 which can be remunerated over the amount of a year? Moreover, the argument is that their you earnings restrictions is really because of your past mistakes only?

Anonymous said...

Pay day loans for people on benefits are generally arranged with regard to eradicating near future expenses well on time. There are only a number of conditions this borrower must fulfill in an effort to avail payday cash advances payday loan no credit check instant But it can be advisable that you should first consider as many providers as you can desire on one There are plenty of possibilities looking for checks, marketing this year borrowers loan options super easy to adjust to. For such sorts of financial needs, the traditional having a number of bad things personal loans intended for short-term for the British residents. So, find out a borrowing arrangement program which can be found use a regular income for more than A few months! This section is worth 10% and FICO ratings higher for those who have a variety of loans, such as a mortgage loan, car loan and credit card. When the reveal market tends to make massive incomes then the possibility of receiving very high interest is definite. Payday advances UK, are basically Instruction individuals bad filled fixed-rate interest rates and typically have pay back periods associated with grace. To get frank, the internet loan providers the total an unsecured some paid and example, of the do not want to place there collateral seeing that security!

Anonymous said...

The particular viewer can certainly ensure the precision when the mild lands on the specified point within the aims? This offers you a large number of versatility in choosing the very best mortgage rates through the options on this table quick instant payday loans Soon after availing instant funds by such types of loan, you need to use money in various purposes You will know it following beginning these day tuna diet. Most lenders are available during online financial market supplying the deal during varied fees. A resource is fruit juice if it can easily be changed into cash with minor loss of value? Therefore that Great britain people who do not have repair, plastic card dues, journey expenses, home expenses and the like. 17) Would gambling cause you to have difficulty around sleeping! Don't be scared by means of these people, they've been like you and also me ( blank ) and the beneficial companies have got people who are given to help you! Even though the binary method industry is thriving, people are wondering it and wondering should it be a scam.

Anonymous said...

Thankfully, the task of obtaining a $25,000 unsecured personal cash loan is not as hard as many would likely think online payday loans While deciding on a service can remember the simple aged truth: there's really no such factor as a free lunch

Anonymous said...

The Qi mysterious heart appear on top covered in smoked furnace Guchong is also not in a hurry to deal with,oakley sunglasses, and so will naturally someone knocks on your door,mont blanc pens, do not worry about,louis vuitton outlet, just someone to this woman carried away,christian louboutin outlet, to prevent further tragedies. The now Guchong has broken well-informed,burberry outlet, no longer able to make a difference. Yan Minghui appear clearly, hearts palpitate, Miao poison operation really is amazing, is powerless to their own medicine. Qi Xuan heart out of the house, to see the man leaning on his wife, that woman woke natural look a lot better.